BOOK
REVIEWS in their published format
- 106 KB, pdf format
Dr. Muhamed Borogovac
(2000).
War in Bosnia and Herzegovina: Political Aspects
Zadar,
Narodni list
"It's
high time to come to the aid of the patriotic forces
fighting against the forces of betrayal and division
of Bosnia...I am writing this book in haste, before
it is too late, while it is still possible to say NO!
to the division of our homeland...."
Quote
from the introduction to Dr. Muhamed Borogovac's book.
In a
number of books which have appeared in recent years about
the war in Bosnia and Herzegovina, its causes, goals, resolutions,
and perpetrators, the Bosniaks, including Dr. Muhamed Borogovac,
have created facts, distorted reality, and "invented
myths and legends", according to Mladen Ancic (author
of Who is to blame for Bosnia), in order to legalize their
political desires for their own state. In the event that
this goal should prove unattainable, they attempt to accuse
others of treason and of dividing the state.
This
book represents another of the hastily prepared interpretations
of the recent political history of Bosnia and Herzegovina,
and its goal is to convince the readers that a conspiracy
and sellout of Bosnian interests exist. It is written in
a superficial manner, is poorly documented, and lacks credibility.
The author's use of crass language seems intended to cater
to the tastes of the "lower classes". The book
is a consequence of the political battle between various
Muslim political groups struggling for power and position
in a future state of Bosnia. Dr. Borogovac is a member of
an opposition group operating on a different continent,
and his political activities directed against his country's
government appear tailored to please the host country, and
not to persuade his readers. The book sets the goal of proving
the thesis that conspirators and traitors are endangering
a unitary and sovereign Bosnia and Herzegovina. The role
of chief conspirator and traitor is played by the present,
charismatic president of Bosnia and Herzegovina, Alija Izetbegovic.
Facts and events are either invented or analyzed on the
basis of invalidated theses. The proofs offered are impossible
to verify, perceptions are highly subjective, personal military
experiences are rarely provided, and experiences of others
are related secondhand. The book is intended as testimony,
but lacks an academic, persuasive explanation of the war,
and neglects the historical-political influences. It follows
the current mode of books on the Bosnian issue, written
by native and foreign authors, who wish to use their short-lived
experiences and engagements on former Yugoslav territory
to form evaluations, offer advice, and share their feelings
about a war which is incomprehensible to them and thus can
only be explained in very general terms (most consider it
a noble struggle based on atavistic passions).
Dr.
Borogovac's book reveals itself in its intentions, language,
and structure as a book which has been written "on
orders", as it indefatigably repeats certain basic
ideas about indivisibility, sovereignty, historical opportunity,
and so on. The Bosniacs are represented as the only nation
that opposes the division of the state, the only nation
capable of democracy and building a civil society. Borogovac
further states that, along with the two main enemies, Serbs
and Croatians, Alija Izetbegovic and his cohorts have transformed
victories into defeats by signing treasonous capitulation
treaties and agreements, dividing and giving away parts
of the state, and therefore depriving the Bosniacs of their
state, which belongs to them based on God's (Allah's) decree
and historical rights.
Dr.
Borogovac is an educated mathematician, who participated
at the onset of the war in the formation of the Army of
Bosnia and Herzegovina in Tuzla. Later he fled in fear and
uncertainty to Croatia, and then to the United States, where
he teaches college mathematics and is active as a member
of the Bosnian Congress, which operates outside Bosnia.
He is an opponent of Alija Izetbegovic and his policies,
which led to the Dayton Agreement and the current blueprint
for Bosnia and Herzegovina. Borogovac considers Dayton and
all other signed agreements a form of capitulation, leading
to the disappearance of the state in which apparently only
one nation resides: Bosniacs. He holds that the interests
and existence of the "thousand year long state and
Bosnian nation" (sic) have been betrayed, and unsystematically
utilizes alleged "evidence" to reveal the pro-Serbian
politics of Alija Izetbegovic, which expose him as a false
Muslim believer, a declared Serb, and a Bosnian traitor.
The main basis for the right of the Bosniacs to a state
is, in his view, the international recognition of Bosnia
and Herzegovina: if the world has recognized the state,
then it exists as one state, one nation, language, history,
and culture. He considers the desires of the Serbs and Croats
for equality nationalistic, because their civil equality
in Bosnia and Herzegovina is ensured by Bosnian tolerance
and openness. Borogovac further argues that Bosnia and Herzegovina,
because of Dayton and other actions of Izetbegovic, has
been divided and no longer exists. Republika Srpska is only
a temporary entity; when the right moment for secession
arrives, it will first secede from Bosnia and Herzegovina
and then join with the Serbian Republic of Yugoslavia. He
finds the causes for the war in the past, in the Second
World War, when Bosnia and Herzegovina was a victim of nationalistic
incursions.
The
same themes are constantly repeated: one state (unitary),
in which the most populous nation (Bosniacs), rules. His
goal is to appeal to the emotions of the Bosniacs by means
of the most simplistic political messages, and to encourage
them to be exclusionary and radical as well. All agreements
and discussions on a state framework satisfactory to all
three constitutionally protected nations are considered
traitorous and in violation of the international principles
prohibiting change of borders. The only solution, therefore,
is a Bosnian civil state in which one citizen has one vote.
All the agreements, Washington and Dayton and others, are
capitulations and invalid. Everything should begin anew,
from the moment of recognition of Bosnia and Herzegovina
by the international community, as this represented complete
freedom to create a Bosnian (Muslim) state. Such a simplistic
interpretation of the historical-political situation in
Bosnia and Herzegovina cannot be considered a serious analysis
of more current Bosnia-Herzegovinian history, but only as
a superficial, reader-friendly pamphlet in service of political
goals. The Bosnian Congress and its members participated
in the last elections and have joined the Alliance for Change
bloc. Borogovac's book has apparently served as election
propaganda material and not as a serious academic investigation
of the continuing burning issue of Bosnia.
Miroslav
Međimorec